Shocking Things About Lobotomy: What are the Medical Reasons Why Frontal Lobotomies Happened?

67

By rochelj

The entire story of pre frontal lobotomies is shocking.

The front of the brain coordinates and organizes oneself.

Lobotomies destroyed high cognitive functioning.

It truly is hard to understand how physicians, who are generally intelligent, highly educated, and dedicated to helping their patients, could participate in such a travesty, and how someone could win a Nobel Prize for developing a form of surgery that left over 40,000 mental cripples in the United States alone.

One famous such story is with Rosemary Kennedy.

She was mildly mentally disturbed and her father was bothered by her behavior.

He arranged for her to have a lobotomy, which made her permanently severely retarded and reduced her to living in an institution for the rest of her life.

Such stories are a tragedy.

Unfortunately, sometimes medical procedures go public before sufficient research has been done into it, leading to catastrophic results.

In the case of lobotomy, an experiment had been done on one chimp, and on that basis so many humans were subjected to this horror.

The whole procedure should have been researched much further before being allowed to go public.

There may have been many other reasons why positive effects were shown on the chimp's behavior, and the negative effects far outweigh the positive.

Perhaps some of the doctors were just trying to gain fame by doing these procedures.

In that time there was no FDA and there were no associations to prevent cruelty, so they tried out any ideas because things were so desperate and out of control.

They finally caught on to the problems with it much later.

If something like this would happen nowadays, it would hopefully be realized much sooner.

To a somewhat more mild degree, we unfortunately see similar stories nowadays- for example, with drugs- we constantly hear about different medicines which were being prescribed to many people and then they are taken off the market due to significant and disastrous side effects that the drugs have caused.

So many lives could have been saved or lived better if more research would be done prior to legalizing these drugs.

Let us learn from the past, so that history should not have to repeat itself.

Comments

Ardie profile image

Ardie Level 8 Commenter 6 months ago

No wonder the procedure is often used or talked about in horror movies as a means of torture, how awful! This is why I stay away from trial therapies and medications. Yikes!

CWanamaker profile image

CWanamaker Level 5 Commenter 6 months ago

Interesting, the history behind the lobotomy is just as horrid as the procedure itself is. Poor chimp.

rochelj profile image

rochelj Hub Author 6 months ago

to Ardie, yes, because so many people had horrible experiences with it, I suppose it then became an ideal theme for horror movies, but for some people in history, this was reality, an inescapable torture inflicted on them.

to CWanamaker, yes, poor chimp. we can say that about all animals that are cruelly used for scientific experiments (and unfortunately sometimes humans were used too for experiments!)

Thank you to both of your for your feedback!

Nell Rose profile image

Nell Rose Level 8 Commenter 6 months ago

Hi, I remember seeing a TV Film about this, a women had the procedure done, and according to the film she was so much better!! yeah right! it was an awful thing, and as you say so many doctors are using drugs for the same thing today, especially children with adhd!

rochelj profile image

rochelj Hub Author 6 months ago

Hi Nell Rose, you are right that it is doubtful that the women got better from this procedure. was the film based on a true story?

yes, it was awful, and you have a point about the ADHD drugs nowadays.

thanks for your comment!

Submit a Comment
Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.



    • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
    • Comments are not for promoting your Hubs or other sites

    Please wait working